You are here
The Top Gear car review:Audi A1
For:Superbly built and luxurious alternative to a Mini
Against:Doesn't drive like its sportier rivals despite costing a fair bit more
1.4 TFSI 140 Sport 3dr
The littlest Audi gets Audi’s littlest engine: a dinky three-pot petrol. Paul Horrell has a spin
Can the 231bhp micro-hot-hatch do the business on British roads? Paul Horrell reports
A legendary name from the Group B era returns as a sensible four-wheel-drive hot hatch. Paul Horrell reports
The A1 Quattro is such a brilliant surprise. 249bhp of Quattro AWD stuffed into a tiny Audi. Beautifully mental
Verdict? Those looking for a classy, comfortable and luxurious city car will think it’s a lovely thing. Sadly though, the drive lets it down and that lack of thrills will deter the Stigs amongst you.
What we say:
Ok, so it's a disguised Polo. But it's quite well disguised and just consider the quality and image
What is it?
Audi’s first foray into the supermini segment, the A1 is poshing up the parts usually reached by more humble VW Group fare such as the Polo and Fabia. It probably makes sound business sense in today’s market, particularly now the more practical Sportback five-door has joined the range: a compact, frugal-ish hatch with executive pretensions, but you do have to think very carefully about meeting a serious premium over those excellent Polos and Fabias.
A mildly fettled VW Polo, don’t expect dynamic miracles from the A1. It rides better than Audis of old – which isn’t saying much – but lacks the steering feel and, crucially, the spirit and involvement of its most obvious premium rival, the Mini. Choose the right wheel and engine options, by which we mean small and petrol respectively, and you will have yourself a comfortable and refined urban runabout, but the A1 even loses ground to more modest fare like the Ford Fiesta and Citroen DS3 when it comes to giving it some proper beans. Relative excitement is provided by a 1.4 TFSI 185 and a torquey 2.0 TDI 143: while the new S1 is the spiritual successor to the fiendish A1 Quattro.
On the inside
The A1’s cabin is its USP. In a class where overall cost is the main driver of design and finish, Audi is consciously bucking the trend. By offering better-off buyers the chance to have a small car with big-car levels of interior quality, the A1 is distancing itself from the rest of the market. Everything feels genuinely premium in here: switchgear that references the TT and A8 all adds to the appeal.
There is a lack of storage space to contend with, and the rear is relatively cramped and short on the sense of luxury afforded the front, but this is a supermini that is clearly dispensing with practicality for the family buyer in favour of coddling the pocket-executive. Audi also offers the Sportback five-door version but, while access to the rear is easier, it’s not actually any bigger inside.
The A1 feels exceptionally well knocked together, and this should be borne out by a long-lasting, rattle-free ownership. The 1.4-litre TFSI 122 is likely to be the volume option, with 120bhp providing sprightly performance allied with decent economy at over 50mpg, but more fun and refinement are available in the guise of the 1.2-litre TFSI, a petrol unit that returns comparable mpg without the unenviable cold-start rattle. The 1.6 TDI diesel boasts 99g/km CO2 emissions (it does 74.3mpg) and the 2.0 TDI alternative is punchy.
Residuals on the A1 are very strong, as they tend to be on any model with a premium badge. The A1 Sportback might even be a little better than the three-door, given market preferences: this will offset the £560 premium over it.