You are here
The Top Gear car review:Mercedes-Benz CLS Shooting Brake
For:All the usual estate attributes, in a less than usual estate body
Against:Option it right and there's precious little to count against it
CLS 350d AMG Line 5dr 9G-Tronic
More spacious inside than you’d credit and as good-looking outside as you’d hope. Smooth, sophisticated and desirable
All estate cars should be like this – super-fast, with a hint of glamour and glint of fun
What we say:
Another unique niche: elegantly flexible and highly desirable, we're sold on the CLS
What is it?
Simple really, an estate version of Merc’s genre-defining CLS four-door coupe. Except Mercedes doesn’t call it an estate. Far too commonplace. It’s Shooting Brake, and TopGear thoroughly approves of the resurrection of this name, even if the CLS doesn’t strictly conform to the traditional two-door estate body shape.
No matter, this is a car into which Mercedes has carefully packed all the clever estate car touches we’re used to from its cheaper family wagons, while letting the designers have their way with the exterior. They’ve been back to the drawing-board recently too: a mildly facelifted verison has now arrived in showrooms.
The CLS may be based on the now-outgoing E-Class, but the driving experience is more advanced. More mature. More elegant and refined. The CLS cruises as well as you’d hope, with a continental gait that soaks up miles effortlessly. If possible, spec yours with full air suspension – as standard it features conventional steel springs up front and air cans at the back, which gives the ride a very slightly disjointed edge.
Either way, the Shooting Brake handles very well. It has nice, natural steering and controls its weight better than the E-Class. Engine choice is limited to a pair of diesels (have the V6 350 if you can as its smoother, sweeter and swifter than the four cylinder 220), and a single petrol. This could be pointless were it not a 5.5-litre twin turbo V8 with more shove than a rugby scrum and an AMG badge on the flanks.
On the inside
Here’s the surprise. You have relatively low expectations of practicality because of the swoopy styling, but then you open the boot (only you don’t have to, it’s electric) and it’s genuinely big. OK, so the narrow aperture is not Ikea-friendly, but everything else about the Shooting Brake is thoroughly family-friendly – including three seats across the back, instead of the pair in the saloon. The driving environment isn’t maybe as modern and digital as those offered in equivalent Audis and BMWs, but it’s beautifully constructed.
Mercedes offers a beautifully engineered wood floor for the boot; very expensive icing on the cake if you want a load space that’s more for looking at than it is loading stuff into.
It’s not cheap. That’s the first thing to note. The Shooting Brake experience starts at a whisker over £48,000, making it around £13,000 more than the equivalent (and bigger, but outgoing) E-Class estate. But that’s not really the point. This is a different type of car, and if it proves as popular as we believe, then residual values will hold up well. Economy is good too, with the CLS 220d returning 56.5mpg and the swift V6 diesel nearing 50mpg. Even the AMG’s 28mpg is creditable given its pace.
The fastestCLS 63 S 5dr Tip Auto
The cheapestCLS 220d AMG Line 5dr 7G-Tronic
The greenestCLS 220 BlueTEC AMG Line Premium 5dr 7G-Tronic