Search Powered ByAsk.com
on
Survey

Survey

S2000 edges just ahead of a brace of Lexuses. Peugeot is bottom again
S2000 edges just ahead of a brace of Lexuses. Peugeot is bottom again
February 14, 2007

Features


Best/worst for build quality


Good news for Jaguar as the XJ takes second place, otherwise it's Japan trouncing France again

Build a better mousetrap, said Ralph Waldo Emerson, and the world will beat a path to your door. Build a shoddy car, says our survey, and you're probably French.

Yes, the French are in trouble again. Sixteen of the 25 worst-built cars in our survey are the spawn of the unholy Peugeot-Citroen-Renault triumvurate, and it's no surprise to find the Peugeot 807 propping up the list again.

Owners of the ill-fated MPV were shocked by its shoddy electrics and dodgy transmission, as well as excessive road noise and grumbling engines.

To be fair, there's a fair British contingent in the badly-bolted basement too, with three Rovers - the MG TF, MG ZR and 25 - and Land Rover Defender all languishing in the bottom ten.


'It's no surprise to find the Peugeot 807 propping up the list again'

Up at the business end, it's a bun-fight between the Japanese and German manufacturers to prove they can bolt a car together tighter. The Honda S2000 tops the list, with slightly obsessed owners revelling in the tactile 'feel' of the mechanical components and, perhaps a touch worringly, the pleasant smell of their roadster.

The S2000 edges a brace of Lexuses - the RX300 (3rd) and IS200/300 (5th) - the Toyota Landcruiser (7th) and Honda Jazz (6th).

The top ten also finds room for a pair of Audis - the A2 (4th) and old TT (8th) - and the Porsche 911 (10th), while Skoda's Superb achieves an, erm, superb finish in ninth place.

And proving that if you build your mousetrap out of lightweight aluminium, the world will indeed beat a path to your door, the gloriously British Jaguar XJ ranks as the second-best built car around. Stout fellow.


CLICK TO ENLARGE

Releated survey features

Advertisment
Car Reviews

Car Reviews

Search road tests
Search now
Buyer's Guide
BUYING, RUNNING, SELLING

You need cash to buy a motor - our guide to finance will help




Buying a personalised plate? Check out our buyer's guide


NewReg.com

Enter Shell V-Factor's contest to find Britain's Best Driver...

Ad feature
Newsletter
Sign up to our newsletter and keep up to speed with Top Gear

Newsletter
Fast-track your motoring career with the help of Top Gear

Top Gear Careers
Get the Top Gear road test verdict on your next car - only £3

Road Test Reprints
The Top Gear word mark and logo are trade marks of the BBC and are used under licence
Subscribe