Search Powered ByAsk.com
on
Survey

Survey

Nearly every category is topped by Japanese metal
Nearly every category is topped by Japanese metal
February 14, 2007

Features


Best/worst in class


Can you spot the theme here? Japanese cars do well, European cars prop up the bottom of the table

If you want satisfaction, buy from Japan. That's the message from our survey if you break the results down class-by-class. Nearly every category is topped by a sensible, well put-together piece of Japanese metal, and nearly every category sees a badly-built, unreliable European banger at the bottom. Like it or lump it, we're just telling it like it is.

Sports
The Honda S2000 canters to victory in the sports car category, closely pushed by a pair of Mazdas (the MX5 and RX8) and brace of Toyotas (the MR2 and Celica). Smart's tiny Roadster is officially the worst sports car around, but we reckon that's partially due to harsh categorisation. Dishonourable mention, then, goes to the second-bottom Merc CLK, which owners found bugged by reliability issues.

Luxury
You might expect the German executive barges to walk this one, but no - the Lexus IS200/300 is the top luxury car around. And though the Jaguar marque is languishing in the doldrums, owners haven't been deterred with the XJ and S-Type both recording strong positions. The Mercedes E- and S-Class bring up the rear, with poor reliability causing the problems again.

SUV
It's another victory for Lexus in the 4x4 category, with owners exalting the RX300's combination of bullet-proof build quality and on-road manners. Second place for the Kia Sorento is a great result for a model aimed at the budget end of the SUV market. Mercedes manages to avoid the wooden spoon in this category, but only just - the utilitarian Jeep Cherokee proving even worse than the M-Class.


'Nearly every category is topped by a sensible, well put-together piece of Japanese metal'

MPV
Brace yourself for a shock: it's a European car in first place. A combination of spaciousness and versatility sees the Seat Altea take the crown in the MPV category, while at the other end - can you tell what it is yet? - the Peugeot 807 lurks apologetically. You really didn't like it, did you?

Medium
It's been a good survey for Skoda. The Czech company has flourished under Volkswagen's ownership, and this top-two finish for the Octavia and Superb helps Skoda edge past Lexus as the best manufacturer overall. It's not a category that makes good reading for the French, though, with Peugeot's 406 and 407 joining the Renault Laguna in the relegation zone.

Compact
It's the celebrity media-appeaser of choice, and it seems the rest of you are keen on the Toyota Prius too. The hybrid tops a Japan-dominated category, beating off strong competition from the Mazda 3 and Honda Civic. Z-list status goes to the Peugeot 307, Renault Megane and Merc A-Class.

Small
Tiny but perfectly formed, the Honda Jazz nipped past Skoda's Fabia and the Fiat Panda to scoop the big prize in this category. And just in case the French manufacturers were getting lonely propping up the table, the Rover 25 gallantly sinks below the Citroen C3 in last place. Good British manners, y'see.


CLICK TO ENLARGE

Releated survey features

Advertisment
Car Reviews

Car Reviews

Search road tests
Search now
Buyer's Guide
BUYING, RUNNING, SELLING

You need cash to buy a motor - our guide to finance will help




Buying a personalised plate? Check out our buyer's guide


NewReg.com

Enter Shell V-Factor's contest to find Britain's Best Driver...

Ad feature
Newsletter
Sign up to our newsletter and keep up to speed with Top Gear

Newsletter
Fast-track your motoring career with the help of Top Gear

Top Gear Careers
Get the Top Gear road test verdict on your next car - only £3

Road Test Reprints
The Top Gear word mark and logo are trade marks of the BBC and are used under licence
Subscribe