Features
76,000 people, 159 cars - it's the UK's biggest independent car satisfaction survey
76,000 people, 159 cars - it's the UK's biggest independent car satisfaction survey
November 1, 2005

Features


Top Gear Survey 2005 - the results


119 Smart Roadster (NEW)

  • Engine/Gearbox Reliability
    3 star rating
  • Electrical Reliability
    2 star rating
  • Brakes/Suspension/Steering
    3 star rating
  • Fit/Finish
    2 star rating
  • Squeaks/Rattles
    3 star rating
  • Performance
    33 star rating
  • Handling
    5 star rating
  • Comfort/Practicality
    3 star rating
  • Customer Care
    1 star rating
  • Ownership Costs
    3 star rating

118 Land Rover Discovery (DOWN)

  • Engine/Gearbox Reliability
    2 star rating
  • Electrical Reliability
    2 star rating
  • Brakes/Suspension/Steering
    3 star rating
  • Fit/Finish
    2 star rating
  • Squeaks/Rattles
    3 star rating
  • Performance
    32 star rating
  • Handling
    3 star rating
  • Comfort/Practicality
    3 star rating
  • Customer Care
    3 star rating
  • Ownership Costs
    1 star rating

117 MG TF (DOWN)

  • Engine/Gearbox Reliability
    2 star rating
  • Electrical Reliability
    2 star rating
  • Brakes/Suspension/Steering
    3 star rating
  • Fit/Finish
    2 star rating
  • Squeaks/Rattles
    2 star rating
  • Performance
    34 star rating
  • Handling
    3 star rating
  • Comfort/Practicality
    2 star rating
  • Customer Care
    2 star rating
  • Ownership Costs
    3 star rating

116 Mercedes CLK (DOWN)

  • Engine/Gearbox Reliability
    3 star rating
  • Electrical Reliability
    1 star rating
  • Brakes/Suspension/Steering
    3 star rating
  • Fit/Finish
    3 star rating
  • Squeaks/Rattles
    4 star rating
  • Performance
    33 star rating
  • Handling
    3 star rating
  • Comfort/Practicality
    3 star rating
  • Customer Care
    2 star rating
  • Ownership Costs
    2 star rating

115 Mercedes C-Class (UP)

  • Engine/Gearbox Reliability
    2 star rating
  • Electrical Reliability
    2 star rating
  • Brakes/Suspension/Steering
    3 star rating
  • Fit/Finish
    3 star rating
  • Squeaks/Rattles
    3 star rating
  • Performance
    33 star rating
  • Handling
    3 star rating
  • Comfort/Practicality
    2 star rating
  • Customer Care
    2 star rating
  • Ownership Costs
    2 star rating


'The service at the Fiat main dealer was so poor I took the car to an independent' - Yvonne Taylor, Bath

114 Hyundai Trajet (NEW)

  • Engine/Gearbox Reliability
    3 star rating
  • Electrical Reliability
    3 star rating
  • Brakes/Suspension/Steering
    2 star rating
  • Fit/Finish
    2 star rating
  • Squeaks/Rattles
    2 star rating
  • Performance
    31 star rating
  • Handling
    2 star rating
  • Comfort/Practicality
    3 star rating
  • Customer Care
    3 star rating
  • Ownership Costs
    2 star rating

113 Mercedes C-Class Sport Coupe (UP)

  • Engine/Gearbox Reliability
    3 star rating
  • Electrical Reliability
    2 star rating
  • Brakes/Suspension/Steering
    3 star rating
  • Fit/Finish
    3 star rating
  • Squeaks/Rattles
    3 star rating
  • Performance
    33 star rating
  • Handling
    3 star rating
  • Comfort/Practicality
    3 star rating
  • Customer Care
    2 star rating
  • Ownership Costs
    1 star rating

112 Volkswagen Polo (UP)

  • Engine/Gearbox Reliability
    2 star rating
  • Electrical Reliability
    2 star rating
  • Brakes/Suspension/Steering
    2 star rating
  • Fit/Finish
    3 star rating
  • Squeaks/Rattles
    3 star rating
  • Performance
    32 star rating
  • Handling
    3 star rating
  • Comfort/Practicality
    2 star rating
  • Customer Care
    2 star rating
  • Ownership Costs
    3 star rating

111 Alfa Romeo 147 (DOWN)

  • Engine/Gearbox Reliability
    2 star rating
  • Electrical Reliability
    2 star rating
  • Brakes/Suspension/Steering
    2 star rating
  • Fit/Finish
    3 star rating
  • Squeaks/Rattles
    4 star rating
  • Performance
    34 star rating
  • Handling
    4 star rating
  • Comfort/Practicality
    3 star rating
  • Customer Care
    1 star rating
  • Ownership Costs
    1 star rating

110 Fiat Seicento (DOWN)

  • Engine/Gearbox Reliability
    3 star rating
  • Electrical Reliability
    3 star rating
  • Brakes/Suspension/Steering
    2 star rating
  • Fit/Finish
    2 star rating
  • Squeaks/Rattles
    1 star rating
  • Performance
    2 star rating
  • Handling
    1 star rating
  • Comfort/Practicality
    1 star rating
  • Customer Care
    2 star rating
  • Ownership Costs
    4 star rating


CLICK TO ENLARGE

Advertiser links

Archived Content

You've found a page archived from the old TopGear.com website. As you probably noticed, TopGear.com had a major revamp in October 2008 but we left these pages up in case you missed them. Check out the new site links at the top or go straight to the homepage.

Advertisement