Sam Philip18 May 2011

Analogue vs digital?

Nissan GT-R and Vauxhall’s VXR8 fight it out in the new issue of TopGear magazine, on sale now

Analogue vs digital?

What's better: analogue or digital? Naturally aspirated V8 or twin-turbo tech? Manual transmission or paddle-shift DSG?
 
These are important questions. Questions about the very soul of fast cars. And in June's issue of TopGear magazine - in all good newsagents today - Tom Ford and I attempt to provide definitive answers... by whanging the Vauxhall VXR8 and Nissan GT-R across the Peak District and then arguing like a pair of schoolchildren.
 
This was the thinking: these are two cars that represent polar opposite takes on the performance car formula: the GT-R has been praised and criticised in equal measure for its reliance on technology, while the VXR8 has faced the same kind of love/hate bipolarity for its basic brute-force-and-ignorance approach.
 
Tom Ford - who isn't here to defend himself, so I shall unfairly paraphrase him - believes the GT-R to be superior. The Nissan, he points out, is far quicker, more powerful and packs enough technology to embarrass a NASA space mission. Anyone who clings to old-school V8 muscle cars in the face of such scientific supremacy, he argues, might as well revert to sending messages by telegram and whittling their own furniture.
 
Because I possess a soul, I know Tom Ford to be wrong. Mathematically better - faster, more powerful, grippier - isn't the same as emotionally better. The VXR8 will be slower along any road than the GT-R, but you'll have more fun getting there. Not everything is better done by technology: a £10 Casio digital watch can record your lap time to the nearest thousandth of a second while letting you know what time the stock markets open in Shanghai, but most of us still wear analogue watches.
 
And so, through a succession of extended metaphors and hilarious insults, it goes on. Now here's what we need you to do. First, go and grab yourself a copy of the mag, and digest the feature in all its high-resolution, tyre-smoking glory. Next, come back here and weigh into the debate: what do you want from your performance cars - digital perfection or analogue thrills?
 
And, if you want to continue the argument on Twitter, we're @samphilip and @tomwookieford. If we're near the internet, we'll do our best to bicker with you. 

Now share it...

What do you think?

This service is provided by Disqus and is subject to their privacy policy and terms of use. Please read Top Gear's code of conduct (link below) before posting.