BBC TopGear
BBC TopGear
Advertisement feature
View the latest news

Speed Week 2020: why sports saloons are better as EVs

The Porsche Taycan blew us away at Anglesey. Here's why

Published: 02 Nov 2020

Time for a game of word association. I say ‘sports saloon’, you tell me the first car that comes to mind. I’d wager the answer changes depending on the age you really got into cars.

In my 33 years on the planet, the definition of ‘sports saloon’ seems to have changed a dozen times over. From wildly winged Subarus and Mitsubishis of the late Nineties, via subtle, classy Germans like the delicate (and compact) B7 Audi RS4 to the quite bonkers 600bhp-plus arena of uber-turbo BMW M5s and AMG E63s. Not to mention their M8 Gran Coupe and GT63 4dr cousins.

Advertisement - Page continues below

But I think it’s time it changed again. The Porsche Taycan is an utterly spellbinding machine – it too offering 600bhp-plus pace, if you go for the Turbo S – and one which returns the fast four-door to its roots. Yep, despite a massive socket where you’d normally find a fuel cap and acres of wire curled up in its boot, I reckon this is the super saloon as it was always meant to be. Subtle.

I grew up reading about Jaguar XJRs and E39 M5s, cars with whopping great V8s scurried beneath bodywork barely changed over standard. Subtle was their selling point; us enthusiasts got to have our fun on the sly. I’m not saying I don’t adore the grumbly V8 of AMG’s latest E-Class, and I’ve definitely enjoyed just how riotously rear-led the balance of its four-wheel drive system is. But there’s no escaping a twin-turbo, quad-tailpipe saloon with its sort of swagger has lost the Q-car feel we used to find abundant in this corner of the market. Instead, we get the opposite: M Sport and AMG Line body kits thrust upon company-car-list diesels.

Delete the badges from your Taycan, though – sealing shut the can of worms about Turbo badging on a car without turbos – and the subtle sports saloon may well be back. It’s jaw-dropping to look at, but courtesy of clean curves rather than beefcake wings or splitters. Pick a dark colour and it’ll blend in for all but those in the know. Just like an E39 M5 always did…

Then there’s its biggest asset: noise, or lack thereof. We’re all suckers for big V8s but if you want to slink around unnoticed – supercar power in a saloon body – today’s overendowed four-doors just won’t allow it. The wholly electric Taycan is inherently hushed, though, and will zip around at quite absurd pace without disturbing the peace or disrupting anyone’s day.

Advertisement - Page continues below

It doesn’t behave boisterously or slide around manically like an AMG – or, indeed, a 911 – but away from YouTube that’s not a relevant criticism. On a dank, wintry B-road you’ll be far more impressed by just how cleverly it shuffles its prodigious power around, flattering its driver while asking astoundingly little of them when they’re not really in the mood. Well, apart from a very elongated coffee break every few hundred miles to recharge its batteries.

Spend a bit of time in a Taycan, having fun on your own terms without peacocking to others, and you’ll question how necessary the bombast of its more conventionally powered rivals really is. It’s fair to say 2020’s been utterly rubbish, but in our little corner of the world, it’s given us the most convincing EVs yet. Right at the top of the tree is the mesmerising Taycan. So brilliant, it should rewrite what we expect from a sports saloon.

Top Gear

Get all the latest news, reviews and exclusives, direct to your inbox.

More from Top Gear

See more on Electric

Subscribe to the Top Gear Newsletter

Get all the latest news, reviews and exclusives, direct to your inbox.

By clicking subscribe, you agree to receive news, promotions and offers by email from Top Gear and BBC Studios. Your information will be used in accordance with our privacy policy.

BBC TopGear

Try BBC Top Gear Magazine