BBC TopGear
BBC TopGear

Opinion: we need to burn petrol the *right* way

There's still a place for petrol-powered cars in our shiny EV future, our staffer argues

Published: 10 Sep 2020

Here’s a little taster of what’s facing automobiles, and those who make them, at the moment. A global pandemic affecting manufacturing, logistics, parts supply and sales. A gigantic recession, with millions out of work, so not really in the market for a new car. Cities taking back streets for pedestrians. Diesel is as hated and feared as Agent Orange. Governments across the northern hemisphere are set to ban new dino-juice-powered vehicles from their roads. EVs and charging points are springing up everywhere, even as people argue until they’re blue – or indeed red – in the face, about where we’re going to get the power from, how environmentally sound the new tech is and whether this whole ‘electric’ thing is about to fall in a heap.

And then there’s the big question that gets mooted any time a car enthusiast talks about the onslaught of electrification: how can it possibly be as good as petrol? There’s no sound, no vibration, no surge of joyous acceleration as the revs hit the sweet spot, and – perhaps most importantly – no interaction. A petrol-powered car is something that requires understanding, ability and, on occasion, genuine sympathy to get the most out of. An electric car requires none of that. There’s no mastery, no controls to adapt to beyond a steering wheel, something that makes it go faster, and something that makes it stop.

Advertisement - Page continues below

Right now, we’re in a state of flux – hardly a day goes by without another EV announcement, but, at the same time, we’re inundated with multi-thousand-horsepower supercars that can drain their fuel tanks in minutes. We get the feeling of being pulled in two opposite directions, like a child of divorce, just without the weirdness of meeting Dad’s new friend, Sarah.

Electrification might feel like a bit of a moot point at the moment, considering how expensive they all seem to be – £40,000 for a Hyundai, £50,000 and up for a Tesla, and around £80,000 for anything European. But it’s not always going to be like this – if you think about it, the electrification of cars could very easily follow the template set down by the electrification of watches.

When the very first quartz watch, the Seiko Astron, came out in December 1969, it cost 1250 Freedom Francs. And that sounds pretty reasonable, until you do the math and find that, in 1969, $1250 could buy you eight brand-new Omega Speedmasters. To do the same today in England will leave you about £30,000 worse off than when you started.

In 1989, the Casio F-91W – y’know, the one that all the Shoreditch hipsters wear – debuted, relying on the same technology as the mesmerisingly expensive Astron did two decades earlier. But its price? Well, the Spring/Summer 1990 Argos catalogue lists a heady asking price of £7.75. And, in 2020, we found a brand-new F-91W for sale... for £7.80.

Advertisement - Page continues below

So what are we saying here, aside from the fact that a Casio might be the bargain of the century? Well, it’s that new technology starts off expensive, then gets cheaper as the costs of production go down – especially if the technology it relies on becomes easy and cheap to mass-produce.

So, we’re almost definitely heading towards a future where the choice between electric and petrol won’t be down to price. And not refill times, either – fast charging is reaching the stage where a 20-minute top up yields hundreds of miles of range. And, let’s not forget, one where governments (excluding America, it seems) are going to continue clamping down on any kind of polluting vehicle.

But we think there’s another way. Current estimates put the number of cars driving around the face of planet Earth at nearly 1.5 billion. Yep, 1,500,000,000 cars, the vast majority of which burn a fuel of one kind or another. And, using some Top Gear maths, we’d say about 1,400,000,000 of them are boring boxes, bought purely because that was the rational choice at the time, or because that’s what the budget allowed. So that leaves one in every fifteen that are truly loved, interesting, classic, retro or some combination of all of the above.

Now imagine replacing 14 out of 15 cars with electric vehicles. Very soon, they won’t be any more expensive or harder to use than a petrol one. And, in most cases, much easier. If we assume a very generous 200 grams of CO2 per kilometre of your average fuel-powered car, and racking up 10,000km a year, we’re talking about 2,800,000,000 fewer tonnes of CO2 going into the atmosphere every year. Yes, 2.8 billion tonnes of CO2. That still leaves 100 million petrol-powered cars for enthusiasts to lust after, buy, restore and cherish (and no diesels, because they have never, ever been interesting, outside of the Le Mans 24 Hour).

Top Gear

Get all the latest news, reviews and exclusives, direct to your inbox.

And it gets better. Look at the odometer readings of old supercars – even the ones that have been enjoyed, not just stored for hateful speculation – and you’ll see that they’ve only racked up a few thousand kilometres a year at the most. So, even assuming terrible CO2 figures, we’re only talking about 100,000,000 cars doing 3,000 kilometres per annum. Even at 600g/km – more than the Bugatti Chiron and Ferrari Enzo pump out – that still only works out to 180,000,000 tonnes of CO2 a year. A decent chunk, of course, but a 93.5 per cent reduction on what we’re doing now, while still enjoying everything that makes a petrol-powered car great – the involvement and engagement in the process, the perfect combination of man and imperfect machine, working in harmony.

It’s pretty obvious by now that a seismic shift from coal and dino-juice to renewable energy – and, by extension, electric cars – is necessary for our air to stay breathable and for our oceans not to turn into simmering vats of acid. Our argument is that to burn petrol, it has to be worth it. Don’t fritter it away commuting in boring cars – volts will handle that just as well as V-Power, and often better. If you’re going to burn petrol, let it be the right way: loving every second of it.

More from Top Gear

See more on Electric

Promoted Content

Subscribe to the Top Gear Newsletter

Get all the latest news, reviews and exclusives, direct to your inbox.

By clicking subscribe, you agree to receive news, promotions and offers by email from Top Gear and BBC Studios. Your information will be used in accordance with our privacy policy.