You are here

Overall verdict

The Top Gear car review: Jaguar XF

Overall verdict
The class-leading dynamics have been preserved and the new interior is in a different world, but whether it's enough to reverse the model’s drift towards market indifference is moot


Interior is now world-class, handling and ride are as sublime as ever, handsome in the right spec


Engines aren’t the sweetest, real world fuel consumption not as good as claimed, get the spec wrong and kiss goodbye to any semblance of street cred


What is it?

Is the executive saloon having an existential crisis? Well the words ‘executive saloon’ are a tough sell, let’s be honest. In these strangest of times, the idea of ascending the corporate ladder and rewarding yourself with a large-ish four-door car seems more outdated than ever. Doesn’t it play to the sort of mind-set that propelled a variety of Seventies and Eighties BBC sitcom characters into thigh-slapping bother? It’s certainly difficult to imagine a senior software engineer in the Google-plex plumping for one. And as we know, software engineers are taking over the world.

Jaguar is probably more wedded to a fusty old stereotype than most. While new boss Thierry Bolloré ponders the brand’s potentially all-electric future, running the numbers on what was once the company’s bread and butter will have him reaching for strong medication or a stiff drink. The XF sold 16,024 units throughout Europe in 2016, which dropped to 5,935 in 2019. This is obviously sub-optimal, and a scenario that won’t have been helped by what was lurking round the corner…

It’s a downward spiral the XF in itself has done nothing to deserve, regardless of macro trends and the machinations of the apocalyptic four horsemen. As has noted, the XF is possessed of the sweetest handling and ride balance in its class. Maybe no one cares so much about that stuff any more. What they do care about is interior quality and connectivity, two areas in which the XF was rather less competitive. This major mid-life update addresses that, as well as revising the engine line-up and substantially streamlining the model hierarchy: from 64, there are now 28 derivatives, and just three engines – a 201bhp, 2.0-litre four-cylinder diesel with a 48V mild-hybrid, and a 2.0-litre petrol, in 247bhp and 296bhp form. Prices now start at £32,585, which is significantly less than key rivals, and £2.5k less than the outgoing car. Jaguar says this is part of a revised commercial strategy, and it helps reduce manufacturing complexity. But it also suggests a reversal of fortune.

Still, keep calm and carry on. There’s the obligatory exterior makeover, covering all the usual facelift bases. The front end is punchier, with a more aero-efficient bumper, bigger air intakes and slimmer LED headlights with a ‘double J’ design. The Jaguar ‘leaper’ logo is on the side vents, and laser-etched within the headlights. The rear end has an enlarged diffuser and redesigned bumper which enhances its stance. As ever with Jaguar, the upshot is a car that looks substantially cooler in R-dynamic spec, gloss black working much better with the car’s fundamentally fine proportions than a more chromey finish. Jaguar has never been much good at alloy wheels, but of the 12 available five are new. There’s no question this is a seriously handsome car, but is that enough?

Highlights from the range

Title 0–62 CO2 MPG BHP Price
The fastest
2.0i [300] Portfolio 4dr Auto AWD
5.9s 171g/km 37.7 300 £47,530
The cheapest
2.0d Prestige 4dr
9.8s 124g/km 57.6 163 £34,725
The greenest
2.0d Portfolio 4dr
9.8s 124g/km 57.6 163 £38,675