Opinion

Is the new electric BMW M3 a surefire hit... or a miss? Have your say

But before you do, allow Top Gear's editorial team to have an argument first

Published: 18 Aug 2026

Ollie Kew: “This is the right side of innovative. Handsome, even”

I might have to join BMW’s designers in their witness protection programme for this, but I like it. Could’ve been a whole Luce worse. Cover the badges and it looks like a BMW. There’s a tasteful amount of historic nods without going retro or pastiche. And all the while, the haters can be pacified by the fact there’s still going to be a similar looking version with a straight six behind that shark snout. 

Compared to some of the utter horrors perpetrated by the BMW design haus this decade (iX, XM, 2 Series Gran Coupe, M4, 7 Series, X7...) this is the right side of innovative. Handsome, even. And more interesting – more experimental – than the Taycans and EQEs of the world.

Advertisement - Page continues below

Greg Potts: “I can’t say I’m spying many links to the neat little E30”

BMW’s M department has thrown the clean, Bauhaus-spec Neue Klasse design book in the bin and gone all in with, well... everything for its first electric M3. I’ve seen London buses narrower than that diffuser, and I can’t say I’m spying many links to the neat little E30. Still, at least the interior will appeal to those who used to wrap the slats of their kidney grilles in M Sport colours.

On that note, presumably the combustion-engined car will get a reworked front end for cooling purposes, and hopefully BMW sees fit to stick on a normal set of wheels at the same time. It’s that version that everyone will buy too, even if the production EV does get 1,000bhp.

Advertisement - Page continues below

Top Gear
Newsletter

Get all the latest news, reviews and exclusives, direct to your inbox.

More from Top Gear

Loading
See more on Opinion

Subscribe to the Top Gear Newsletter

Get all the latest news, reviews and exclusives, direct to your inbox.

By clicking subscribe, you agree to receive news, promotions and offers by email from Top Gear and BBC Studios. Your information will be used in accordance with our privacy policy.

BBC TopGear
magazine

Subscribe to BBC Top Gear Magazine

find out more