Gaming

Grand Theft Auto 2 review: the weirdest GTA game of them all

In every technical way it was better than GTA1... but after 'Driver' came and conquered, wasn't as cutting edge

Published: 16 Nov 2026

Following up the original Grand Theft Auto with a gloomy, neo-noir crim sim, which looked like a sort of sweary, ultraviolent Dick Tracy, was a bit of a surprise. It's as if the Spice Girls had followed up their first album with an experimental jazz record; a few fans might have enjoyed a version of Spice Up Your Life performed entirely on the theremin, but it certainly wouldn't be what anyone was expecting.

Grand Theft Auto 2 was, and remains, a good game, but there's no doubt that, in the context of what GTA has become, it was an aberration. To this day, GTA 2 remains the title that fits least comfortably into a series trajectory that has arrived at GTA 6 and hints at an alternative reality where the GTA series became increasingly obscure instead of the all conquering, tabloid-troubling success it is today.

Advertisement - Page continues below

With the benefit of distance, and the knowledge that it was a freak one-off, we can finally appreciate the aesthetic left turn that GTA 2 took. The game's location, called Anywhere City, is a bizarre mix of Tim Burton's Gotham City and Blade Runner's neon lights, populated by Claymation criminals and Elvis impersonators.

Of course, the irony is that before you even booted up the game, there was a live action intro sequence filmed on the streets of New York City, that looked like a nailed-on mood piece for the following game, Grand Theft Auto 3. It's sort of like Rockstar knew what the fans really wanted, but then made GTA 2 anyway.

Play it now and it's clear this is a much more sophisticated game than the first one. For a start, the driving controls were tighter and more manageable and the top-down camera did a better job of keeping up with vehicles travelling at speed. A new faction system made this game a nightmare for people-pleasers, as completing jobs for one syndicate would raise the ire of the others.

Hard as it is to believe, the game also introduced an option to save your game that was entirely missing in the original. You had to enter a church and pay $50,000 to retain your progress, which is almost certainly supposed to be some sort of satirical statement about organised religion.

Advertisement - Page continues below

Grand Theft Auto 2 offered a richer, more involved storyline and greater mission variety across its vast, non-linear structure than the first game, so on paper it should have been a slam dunk. This was in almost every way a refinement of the unique formula that had been so unexpectedly successful for the original game.

And yet sales-wise, GTA 2 was only a modest success, shifting around an estimated one and a half to two million units. You might assume the biggest obstacle the game faced was its challenging visual style, which was indeed divisive. In reality, though, it was the unfortunately timed release of the game Driver five months prior, which offered Hollywood car chase thrills in a fully 3D city, all on a humble PlayStation.

The first GTA's positively retro top-down perspective had seemed gutsy and charming in 1997, but two years later with Driver offering a far more immersive take on a similar concept, and selling over double the number of copies, the sequel struggled to make a significant impact.

Of course what happened next, with Grand Theft Auto 3 setting the blueprint for just about every open-world game to follow, is the stuff of legend, but if anything that makes Grand Theft Auto 2 an even more intriguing curio. If you've never played it, secure yourself a copy and play the game that is, by far, the weirdest that GTA has ever been...

Top Gear
Newsletter

Get all the latest news, reviews and exclusives, direct to your inbox.

More from Top Gear

Loading
See more on Gaming

Subscribe to the Top Gear Newsletter

Get all the latest news, reviews and exclusives, direct to your inbox.

By clicking subscribe, you agree to receive news, promotions and offers by email from Top Gear and BBC Studios. Your information will be used in accordance with our privacy policy.

BBC TopGear
magazine

Subscribe to BBC Top Gear Magazine

find out more